Another summer, another search for an artistic director at Mamaroneck’s Emelin Theater. It was confirmed today that Michael Bush is out as artistic director nine months after taking over at the venue on Library Lane.
The former Manhattan Theater Club advisor had big plans for the tiny venue—and kicked them off with a Glen Island party last fall to start the drive for a $10 million expansion of the site. He programmed a “Theater in Concert Festival” last fall that he considered a tasting menu of where he wanted to take the theater. There was cabaret, there was theater, there was music.
He staged “Murderers,” a play he helped develop with playwright Jeffrey Hatcher, but then had to postpone a May production of “Pure Heaven: A Party with Kay Thompson,” when its star, Ruth Williamson, developed throat problems in previews. That production was pushed back to the fall and is now in jeopardy.
Carla Sacks of the Emelin’s press firm Sacks & Co. confirmed that Bush is leaving.
“It is true. Michael has resigned,” Sacks said, adding “both parties are working amicably together to resolve it and move forward.”
Sacks had no further details, but said that summer programming will not be affected by the resignation. “Only the theater program is being affected,” she said.
Sara Feldmann Sheehan confirmed earlier that she is stepping down as president of the Emelin board and will be replaced by Mark D. Ettenger and Seth Kaplan. Feldmann Sheehan said she planned to remain on the board.
It’s been a rocky year at the Emelin. In the spring of 2007, shortly after announcing a $10 million capital program to more than double the venue’s usable space – managing director John Raymond left abruptly, followed soon by the theater’s publicity director.Last September, the Emelin’s board of trustees announced the appointment of Bush as the theater’s new artistic director, in what was seen as a major step in securing the future of the 250-seat Equity house that is home to legitimate theater, a cabaret series, a bluegrass series and a film club.
In making the announcement, Sara Feldmann Sheehan, said Bush was a good fit.
“Michael Bush has the vision, energy and passion we were looking for to take the Emelin Theatre in an exciting new direction,” Sheehan said at the time. “Most importantly, Michael understands that it is crucial to maintain what is beloved about the Emelin, such as its intimacy and sense of community, while continuing to expand our programming to make it relevant to an even larger audience.”
Bush had a decades-long relationship with Manhattan Theatre Club. He was a key lieutenant to the club’s artistic director, Lynne Meadow, and was involved in the development of “Proof” and “Doubt,” two Tony and Pulitzer Prize winners.
In an interview at the time, Bush told me he was looking forward to taking chances in Mamaroneck.
“It’s a risky thing to say ‘Let’s take chances and actually dare to strive for something larger,’ ” he said then.
He gave audiences a glimpse of his theatrical vistion with a November festival – Theatre in Concert – that included plays about Tennessee Williams, cabaret nights, and a bit of bluegrass.
The news of Bush’s departure has to be unsettling for those watching the ambitious capital plan the theater had laid out before his arrival: A $10 million “Next Stage” project would expand the theater’s stage and seating capacity (from 250 to 399), add a film-only theater (allowing for an expanded film series), and a 60-seat “black box” experimental theater. The complex will go from 9,000 square feet to 36,000 square feet.
Bush had ventured from Manhattan Theatre Club before.
In 2002, he left MTC to lead Charlotte Rep in his native North Carolina. After 18 months, he left Charlotte, having presented Hilary Swank in “The Miracle Worker” and several new works, but finding that the community’s support was insufficient to sustain the professional theater. In February 2005, the theater folded.
When he took the Emelin post, Bush said the Charlotte experience taught him to be humble, and that “transition takes time.”
“The board there had given me a mandate to put Charlotte Rep in a national spotlight, which I did very quickly. But the South is a tricky area. There’s no history or tradition of philanthropy. I had tremendous competition from all of the sports. My second season there, the Panthers went to the Super Bowl and my theater was right across the street from the stadium. I was having a hard time drawing in that audience there, so I was trying to create true events. One of the ones I pulled off was getting Hilary Swank there, and we did sell out every night.”
Bush said the experience made him stronger.
“You can’t know success without tasting failure. I’ve had great success and I’ve fallen on my face. I learned more from falling on my face, but I come to this job with a true yin and yang to what life is about – and what success is about.
“I think it has prepared me for what I call Act 2 of my life. And I see the Emelin as a really strong and kind of glorious Act 2,” he said last September.
With Raymond’s departure, and now Bush’s departure, the Emelin, it appears, is ready for Act 3.
Photo by Mark Vergari/The Journal News: Michael Bush at a Midtown Manhattan rehearsal of “Pure Heaven: A Party with Kay Thompson,” which was planned as the spring production at the Emelin, but which was postponed to the fall after its star, Ruth Williamson, developed vocal problems during previews. Bush is out as artistic director after nine months on the job.