I went to see “West Side Story” at Antrim Playhouse in Wesley Hills — or Suffern — last week and I was blown away.
First of all, there’s the space itself, a gem of a theater with a balcony and room for about 200. The stage is deep, the staff is friendly and — if the talent on display last week was any indication — it’s right up there with most professional groups in the region.
Antrim has been around for generations, on Spook Rock Road.
Director Randy Accardi faced an uphill battle with “West Side,” with two major hurdles: Men and dancing, two bains of community theater. But the New Jersey-based director choreographer who staged “Fiddler on the Roof” last spring, knew that with the right cast, total commitment and plenty of time, it wasn’t impossible.
Co-Producer Jim Guarasci is one of my new favorite people. He put the creative team together, helped with the program, raised money, sold cookies and coffee at intermission — and appeared in the show as Gladhand! He’s a dynamo!
It’s been a long and varied season for Antrim. The season started with “Last of the Red Hot Lovers,” “Blood Brothers,” “Snow White,” “A Few Good Men,” “Enter Laughing,” “West Side Story,” and closes with Donald Margulies’ “Brooklyn Boy,”which opens June 13 and runs through June 29.
Guarasci, who owns Pasta Cucina and offers a dinner-theater package, approached area high schools, in search of Jets and Sharks. Accardi cast Tommy Hettrick as Riff and Joshua Harry Lindover — both of New City, both students at Clarkstown High School South — and boy did that casting work. Neither considered himself a dancer coming into the show, but five months of rehearsal with Accardi certainly changed that.
Hettrick is a natural, a sinewy ball of energy who draws the eye. When he’s on stage, he’s captivating, ever in the moment. Lindover, billed as Joshua Lind in the program, is an exceptional dancer and has the acting chops to boot.
The choreography was tight, precise and inspired. Accardi resurrected a dance ballet, performed behind a scrim, and it was just stunning. Dancers in all white performed and then were joined, back to back, by dancers in street clothes. It had the effect of finding the inner angel in these street toughs, and it was something to see.
Purchase College Opera Conservatory grad Marisol Cable lent her incredible voice to the role and was convincing as a young Puerto Rican girl, new to America, who falls for an older boy. That, she explains, is because she has Puerto Rican roots and met her husband in high school — at Clarkstown High School North — when she was 14 and he was 17.
Texas native Nolan Muna was no match for Cable vocally — who, but another opera singer, could be? — but he did an admirable acting job. And his dancing was strong enough that Accardi put him in the dream ballet.
Cristina Farruggia, another Clarkstown South graduate, was pitch perfect as Anita, Bernardo’s girlfriend. She was able to find the comedy and the pathos in the character, and was just riveting. It wasn’t just the red dress. Farruggia, the daughter of opera people, draws every eye when she takes the stage. Her accent was perfect.
The set was minimal in the extreme, with two rolling scaffolds put to use as everything from Doc’s Drug Store to Maria’s fire escape and the highway. The spinning scaffolds and Zack Spitzer’s lights had a dizzying effect — and made the 50-year-old musical seem as fresh as ever. Even the chainlink fence under the highway rolled on and off.
An EXCELLENT ensemble, a lot of work and a fascinating design approach made Antrim’s production of “West Side Story” the most exciting community theater show I’ve seen in years.
I now have another must-see theater season, Antrim’s.
Next year’s spring musical? “Miss Saigon”
Up next at Antrim:
“Brooklyn Boy”
When: June 13 through 29. Performances are Fridays and Saturdays at 8 p.m.; Sundays at 2 p.m.
Where: Antrim Playhouse, Spook Rock Road, Wesley Hills.
Tickets: $16; $2 discount for students and seniors for Friday and Sunday shows only.
Call: 845-354-9503.