When Pleasantville High School’s production of “Fiddler on the Roof” opens tomorrow night, the musical based on Sholom Aleichem’s Russian folk stories will star a bona fide American folk singer – Anthony da Costa – who, at 17, has just released his fourth full-length CD of original songs, “Typical American Tragedy.”
After playing in a middle school band called Us and Him – “doing mainly Red Hot Chili Peppers and Beatles covers” – da Costa began writing and playing his own music. He was 13.
He popped in at open mikes in coffeehouses across Westchester and in New York, found a musical kindred spirit in Croton-based singer and producer Fred Gillen Jr., and now plays showcases, theaters and festivals as far away as Texas and Tennessee.
When “Fiddler” rehearsals took a break for the recent winter recess, da Costa was off to play his music at a folk conference in Memphis.
Closer to home, he’s been opening for the Lower Hudson Valley’s Red Molly on regional dates. (Red Molly’s Abbie Gardner plays on his latest CD.) He also has opened for Livingston Taylor and Susan Werner, and was nominated as Folk Alliance’s “Emerging Artist of the Year.”
Da Costa’s musical influences include Bob Dylan, Dan Bern, Ryan Adams and Damien Rice.
“Typical American Tragedy,” released just last month, has 11 original da Costa songs, from the political “Wall Around Baghdad” to the sentimental “Upstate Living” to a sweet little number called “Carnival,” about a man’s inability to win his girl a prize at a fair.
I went to the carnival
And I didn’t win you nothin’.
You are something special
Wanted to bring you something
Want to show you that I care
With a yo-yo or a stuffed bear.
Because I’ve been waiting on you
To let me in.
But I went to the carnival
And I didn’t win.
But before da Costa had songwriting, he had theater.
In fifth grade, he played Winthrop in Pleasantville High School’s production of “The Music Man.” He was so into the role, he recalls, that he was still speaking with his character’s trademark lisp weeks after the show had closed.
Tevye, the Russian milkman, is no Iowa schoolkid. Putting on Tevye takes a lot of preparation and thought, da Costa says.
“This is 1905 czarist Russia and this is a man with a lot on his plate, a lot to deal with,” da Costa says. “He’s living with six women. He’s kind of outnumbered.
“Trying to raise five daughters in a blue-collar job as a milkman, working hard every day, he dreams of relaxing, but he does it while he’s doing what he has to do to support his family. I admire that,” he says. “And he’s got a great sense of humor.”
Even though his character is all about tradition – the show opens with a stirring, seven-minute song by that title – da Costa says Tevye doesn’t exactly conform to musical theater tradition.
“Tevye is unique in the sense that he breaks down the fourth wall with the audience,” says the Pleasantville junior. “He’s more of a friend to the audience than just putting on a show. I tend to see the people in the room a lot more than if you were playing another traditional theater role.”
But it fits in well with his singer-songwriter side.
“I do a lot of banter and I usually get the audience to sing along,” he says.
As a songwriter, da Costa finds images and parallels that might not have occurred to others. When it’s suggested that his songwriting idol, Dan Bern, likely never sang words like those written by “Fiddler” lyricist Sheldon Harnick, he thinks for a second and says: “Although Dan Bern’s parents are from Lithuania and they escaped persecution for being Jewish…”
Pleasantville’s director Kathleen Donovan-Warren says she chose “Fiddler” after considering the students at her disposal. As the school’s chorus and theater teacher, she knew what she had.
“I knew I had to have a Tevye with the acting and singing chops, but I knew I also had a depth of female talent and this show highlights that depth,” she says.
“He’s got a lot of instinctive talent and instinctive acting ability,” Donovan-Warren adds. “We don’t have to work at it that hard. And he takes direction well.”
On stage, da Costa’s Tevye is a charming mix of ease, weariness and humor. His stage presence is indisputable and his voice has a more conventional musical theater timbre than you’ll hear on his CDs.
Still, the folk music is never far away. Next Thursday, before the second weekend of “Fiddler,” he’ll play at the Westchester Arts Council as part of its “New Voices” series.
Then, the next day, it’s back to the milkman for the final weekend.
Photo by Tania Savayan/The Journal News: Anthony DeCosta plays Tevye in Pleasantville High School’s “Fiddler on the Roof.”
“Fiddler on the Roof”
Where: Pleasantville High School, 60 Romer Ave., Pleasantville.
When: 8 p.m., March 7, 8, 14, 15; 3 p.m., March 9; 1:30 p.m. March 15.
Tickets: $12.
Tickets: $12.
Call: 917-373-6820. (Not 914. It’s a cellphone.)
With: Marlayna Augusto, Emily Band, Peter Berkowitz, Rachel Bloom, Sarah Browne, Joshua Bucheister, Gregg Butler, Diana Chiavetta, Cristina Corvino, Stephanie Corvino, Tomislav Coza, Anthony da Costa, Dana DeSousay, Megan Downey, Rebecca Echevarria, Sandra Edelman, Charlotte Exton, Max Finsmith, Gerardo Torres Flores, Rose Gandalfo, Geena George, Owen Gilroy, Daniel Gilroy, Chelsea Gratz, Jennifer Grom, Angela Guzman, Michele Hartman, Issei Herr, Patricia Hibner, Oliver Hill, Elizabeth Holmes, Natasha Honey, David Hyman, Jaime Katz, Caroline Kelly, Mara Kennedy, Elizabeth King, Rebecca Kaufman, Elizabeth Latella, Frank Leone, Thomas Lombardi, Jenna Margiasso, Emma Maznio, Aimee McGonaghan, Sam Mintzer, Colleen Nuccio, Alexandra Ossowski, Rory Ostrow, Jennifer Padilla, Emily Paruolo, Eamon Pickard, Elizabeth Proehl, Kimberly Puccia, Julia Reilly, Erica Sarro, Jessica Sarubbi, Joseph Scuccimarri, Ben Sherer, Eric Sinski, Brittaney Smith, Emily Taubenblatt, Liane Tomasetti, Staci Tomasetti, Matthew Ultan, Jaclyn Vosburg, Shana Wallace, Michelle Wellansky, Sonia George, Christine Miller, Chelsea Brooks, Stephanie Edlund, William Dietrich-Egensteiner, John Mace, Philip Manzi, Eric Maznio, Alex Poller, Nicholas Prache, Matthew Wolf, Alex Zapletal, Matthew Belanich, Vishal Bhatty, Caitlin Bull, Alex Choy, Allison Clark, David Hyman, William Pedlow, Timothy Solster, Jennifer Steinbeck, Even Stolatis, Zachary Willard, Emma Apecelli, Emily Appel, Jonathan Appel, Rachel Bordin, Lindsay Calhoun, Mark Carlough, Caitlin Casey, Kayla Curran, Jackie D’Arco, Malachi Davis, Andreanna Dempsey, Clare Eichinger, William Elliott, Michael Elliott, Tina Elliott, Wujong Farrant, Matthew Fox, Jaclyn Jasmin, Erin Joenk, Holly Krakowski, Genevieve Oliver, Sophia Paljevic, Michael Phillips, Ariane Prache, Andrew Pugliese, Trevor Roberts, Jake Ruth, Andres Sandoval, William Shum, Esteban Torres, Arielle Trapp, Emily Appel, Leslie Del Mastro, Chloe Gilroy, Elizabeth Peake, Helene Rached, Tiffanie Smith, Jill Sue, Matthew Wolf, Isabelle Franks, Michelle Bauer, Francesca Lucia, Christine Carfaro, Kelsey Connell, Vanessa Nieto, Amanda DiBlasio, Kelsey Connell, Vanessa Nieto, Esther Kim, Jennifer Sparano, Jovienne Trotta, Rachel Bordin, Joshua Bucheister, Oliver Hill, Rachel Karp. Michael Phillips, Jen Steinbeck, Anna Uehara.