Tonight, after the dessert plates have been cleared and everyone’s had their coffee, the lights will go down at the Westchester Broadway Theatre in Elmsford and the spotlight will shine on some remarkable members of the Westchester arts community.
The seventh annual Cab Calloway Lifetime Achievement Awards are the brainchild of the dinner theater’s George Puello. Years ago, Puello found himself going to the funerals of pillars of Westchester’s artistic community and hearing glowing tributes.
“And I said, ‘Wouldn’t it be better to be saying all this things to them instead of about them?’� he recalls.
The name was a no-brainer: Cab Calloway, the hi-de-ho jazz singer and bandleader, lived in Elmsford for 34 years, until his death in 1994.
This year’s black-tie-optional event honors:
• Asbury Summer Theatre in its final season, with the award going to longtime AST member and technical guru Andrew Gmoser;
• Dotti Pustola and Ann Wurzburger, founding members of The Harrison Players;
• Vinny Lopreto, a director and choreographer whose work has been seen across Westchester for years;
• Mara Mills, whose Herbert Mark Newman Theater at the Pleasantville Y was a haven for new and classic works before closing in 2004 after a 13-year run;
• Composer, conductor and musical director Donna Cribari, one of the founders of the Port Chester Council for the Arts;
• Dick Nagle and Jeanne McCabe, who have shared their lives and the stage for more than 30 years;
• Dance teacher and choreographer Selma Rothstein, who has taught dance in Westchester for 60 years. Now she directs “The Tapettes,� a group of tap-dancing senior citizens at the Y in White Plains.
Rothstein, Cribari, McCabe and Nagle gathered at the theater recently to talk about their lives in the arts.
SELMA ROTHSTEIN has been teaching dance at the Y in White Plains for 39 years.
When she was 3 years old, the Yonkers native began studying dance, under Helen Lissauer. She was hooked after the first class.
“When I walked out of that place, I never wanted to do anything else,� she says.
“She saw something in me that gave me a lot of confidence,� Rothstein says.
Rothstein turned pro at 15, a career that ended three years later when she married. Soon she had two kids running around the house — and she was looking for an outlet.
A friend watched the kids, freeing Rothstein up, in 1947, to teach dance to tots at the Jewish Community Center in Yonkers.
“I started the classes and I said, ‘This is what I have to do.’ That started it, and I never stopped.�
Not for 60 years.
She gave them lessons. They gave her “joy, fulfillment, inspiration,� she says.
Some of her former students will be there tonight.
“One started when she was 7. Now she’s 63,� says Rothstein.
Her current students — “The Tapettes� — range from age from 58 to 83, including Sharon Field, who’s been with Rothstein for 18 years.
“I’ve had four back surgeries, somebody else has a new knee, somebody else has new hips. We’ll drag ourselves to that class in casts and on crutches just for what she gives to us. Not just the dance steps, but something that comes from her.�
The Tapettes will perform at Monday’s celebration, wearing T-shirts emblazoned with “Selma’s Girls.�
A former student, Marlene Furtick, became a choreographer and the great Judith Jamison danced her “How Long Have It Been� with the Alvin Ailey Repertory Ensemble.
Furtick, who now leads the Westchester Youth Bureau, says Rothstein is “one of those special people that really had the ability — and still has the ability — to make each and every person who comes to her class feel special.�
DONNA CRIBARI had her light bulb moment — the one that convinced her that she could compose music — in Quebec, when she was asked to compose music for frogs.
Cribari was working at a school where every class — from kindergarten to eighth grade — was required to take ballet and it was her job to play for them one day a week, all day.
“I would play the dance curriculum and creative movement for this ballet teacher� she says.
“At the end of the class, she’d turn to the class and say, ‘We’re going to do improv. So be witches or be frogs.’ Then she’d look at me and say, ‘Play music for the frogs and witches.�
“I played something. I have no idea what. Years later I wrote to her� — Sonia Chamberlain, of the Royal Academy of Dance — “and said, ‘You made me a composer because on the spot I had to create something that was expressive of that.’
“It was a thousand years ago, but it’s something I use every day that I’m still working as a composer.�
If writing music touches her heart, the “community theater thing,� as she calls it, is the “mainstay and joy of my life.�
“The family you make with all these different groups is incredible,� she says.
Cribari makes family at theaters across Westchester, but it all started with her family: Port Chester’s Colangelo-Linen-DelBianco theatrical “syndicate.�
These are the people who started the Port Chester Council for the Arts, which produces shows throughout the summer and brings theater and the arts into classrooms.
Theater is in Cribari’s blood: Her parents met doing community theater in the 1920s — with a Mrs. Tompkins in Mount Vernon.
“In our family, the funny thing is, you have to audition if you’re going to marry one of the people,� she says.
JEANNE MCCABE knew theater was her thing when she played Fidelity Marston in the seventh-grade production of “Father Talks Turkey� at Mount Vernon’s Wilson Junior High.
“When I would say something, everybody laughed. I loved that. I felt everybody was with me. I didn’t know why they were laughing.�
But she was hooked.
She acted in school shows and started studying guitar under Jerry Silverman, who taught her folk music and gave her great advice, McCabe recalls.
“He said, ‘You are a terrible guitarist. Give it up. But you have a great voice and your range is good.’�
She studied voice at Juilliard on weekends and studied theater and psychology at Ithaca College.
Theater and psychology remained mainstays of her life.
She recently retired from a 20-year career as a social worker at an alternative high school in Yorktown, where she found it hard to leave her theater life at the school door.
She began teaching theater and music electives at school, as a way of “helping kids who — like many of us in theater — are not like everyone else.�
She also set up internships for high school students to work at theaters, including Westchester Broadway Theatre. Some of them have gone on to careers in the technical aspects of theater.
When she wasn’t at school, she was in a show.
“The joy I’ve gotten out of doing theater in Westchester is you do something for a few weekends and then you’re somebody else. There’s a whole other life you can live for a while.�
McCabe, who has played leading roles across Westchester in professional and community theater productions, downplays her impact.
“I’ve gotten so much more than I contributed,� she says.
DICK NAGLE, McCabe’s partner of 30 years, also has had two tracks in his life, albeit less compatible ones: theater and fighting fires.
Like Cribari, his parents met doing theater — “parish theater� at St. Simon Stock Parish in the Bronx.
When he was 7, his dad dragged him along to the Tarrycrest Players production of “A Christmas Carol,� where he played Marley and young Dick played Peter Cratchit.
“Years later, when I got to play Scrooge, I thought back and I teased the little guy playing Peter and said, ‘You know what, kid? Stick with it long enough and you can play Scrooge, too.’�
In the 1970s, Nagle co-founded the Mahopac Farm Playhouse and the LaPino Dinner Theater, one of the first dinner theaters in the region, and helped form the Archbishop Stepinac Alumni Theater, which helps to fund the excellent theater program at the Catholic boys school in White Plains.
Nagle credits his mentor, Stepinac’s Rev. Jim Cashman, with encouraging him “as a performer, director and just to be involved in theater on different levels.�
He studied theater at Catholic University in Washington, but left after two years to become a firefighter.
He spent 20 years with the FDNY and was chief in Ridgefield, Conn., for 11 years. He also commuted to his job at the New York State Fire Academy in the Finger Lakes, returning to Westchester on weekends.
When he returned to theater after working as a firefighter, it was at Marymount Manhattan College, where he holds the distinction of being the first male graduate of the previously all-female school.
His two loves, theater and firefighting, converged in 2002, when he did a production of “The Guys� — a play about a firefighter writing the eulogies of his fallen 9/11 comrades — at the Herbert Mark Newman Theater, which was led by Mara Mills, another Calloway honoree on Monday night.
Nagle and McCabe have shared their lives — and the stage — for 30 years, but it was with Ed Shanaphy that Nagle started two theater companies: Mahopac Farm Playhouse and LaPino Dinner Theater, Westchester’s first.
The dinner theater, in Vista, sat 99 people in a space that was so close that actors were practically dancing on the baked potatoes.
“You could smell the pasta,� McCabe quips.
(Top photo: From left, Donna Cribari, Jeanne McCabe, Dick Nagle and George Puello chat at the Westchester Broadway Theatre in Elmsford Sept. 12, 2007. Photo by Stuart Bayer.)
(Second photo: Selma Rothstein at the Westchester Broadway Theatre on Sept. 12, 2007. Photo by Stuart Bayer.)